Culvert Advice -- Plastic vs. Galvanized ? - TractorByNet

I need to put in a 20' culvert to extend a road to an RV pad I am building. I need to be able to drive both a 14,000 # motorhome and my # tractor over the culvert, not at the same time.

I have seen both metal and plastic used, the costs are close in my area.

Which is the preferred type & why?

Second question:

How do I tell what size to use? The county says 12" minimum everywhere, but for the difference in cost I would rather do it right (maybe some overkill) the first time than replace it next year if it is too small.

From the topo map, it looks like the water from 10-20 acres of 15%+ slope drains through this spot. The culvert will have about a 10% slope.

I am sort of leaning to 24" diameter, which only costs twice as much as 12".

The culvert is going into a natural gully and not a ditch. I looks to me like there will be over 3' of fill over the culvert at one end, and over 5' at the other.

Third Question:

Do I need to fill around the culvert with gravel or can I just use the dirt I excavated for the RV pad?

Forth Question:

Should I have some kind of grate to prevent debris from entering the culvert? CurlyDave,

I like plastic since it won't rust.

You need at least 12" of material over the culvert to get the maximum strength. Mine is covered maybe 6"-8" but it handled 55-60,000 pound dump trucks just fine.

I used ABC to cover the culvert since that is what I was using to build the driveway. Most people would use whatever soil they had available.

I think mine is 18" in diameter. I got mine for free so I used it. I don't get much water in mine since the culvert is only about 50 feet from the top of a hill. I would want 18" or larger culvert since I think it would be harder to stop up in the first place and if it did get clogged it should be easier to clean out.

10-20 acres can generate alot of water. Since it sounds like you have a deep ditch a bigger culvert would be better. Bigger than you need is better than not enough culvert. You might want to contact you county extension office and see if they can give you some guidence to size the culvert. 1 inch of rain on 10 acres is alot of water....

Later,
Dan I'm a long way from being an expert here but with the weight on the MH (possible 8-9k# on the rear axle) and not knowing anything about the "dirt" I'd be a little concerned whether the plastic culvert could handle the stress. Does the galvinized steel have spiral flutes? This adds to the strength considerably. The trade off is that somewhere down the road the galv/steel may rust out as zinc is water soluable.

As for the grate, on a 24" culvert one might not be needed depending upon what gets washed down the gully. With a grate you could find yourself having to clean at least once a yr. I'd do some asking around from others in the area that have done it both ways and see what their feeling are.

Up the road a piece at MP #272. Plastic is better than metal for several reasons. First, it will never rust out on you. EVER. Second, get the type with the smooth inner wall. It stays cleaner and doesn't hold silt and debri. As for strenght, both rely on preasure from the fill material being equal on all sides. You need a certain amount of fill on top based on the size of the pipe you install to reach maximum strength. For an RV, you will need this. For a car or light tractor, the amount on top isn't as important.

Since you want to create a crossing over a ravine, go as big as you can. That ravine was created by allot of water. The size of it shoud tell you the amount of flow you have to deal with. 24 inches is a huge pipe and should be able to handle most situations, but there is a reason they make bigger pipes and/or install two side by side.

Putting grates in front will cause more problems than it would solve. Small leaves will wash right through it, but with a grate in front, they will create a dam. It's very rare to see one along highways or anyplace that they are put in profesionally, so I'm thinking you don't need one. I don't have any on mine and so far haven't had any issues.

Backfill is usually with clean soil, but sometimes sand is used instead. Rock isn't any good because of the voids and dificulty in getting it all compacted. At the entrance to the pipe you will need to put something down to stop erosion. I've used sacks of cement for this with good results. Of course, it's not as attractove as rock. If you use rock, be sure it's big enough not to wash away or let the water through it. Small rock is useless during a heavy storm.

And always plan for the very worse that can happen.

Eddie I am with Eddie. Go as big as you can. 10-20 acres draining thru a 6' or 7' deep ravine can be a lot of water. And you want it to go thru the culvert, not over the top.
And as Eddie said, don't use loose rock or gravel for fill. You don't want the water seeping around the sides of the culvert.
I have a 24" culvert in the ditch coming in off the road. I had to have some fill dirt hauled in but it was similar to what I have on my land. Once it is filled and packed, the circular nature of the pipe is very strong. Weight on top tends to push the dirt down around the sides of the pipe. That applies extra pressure to the sides adding support to the top. Due to the depth of my ditch, I have only about 1' fill on top of mine. But when I built my metal building, they brought in all materials on a flat bed semi. No problem at all driving it over the culvert. Oh. mine is metal.

Are you stuck with a lot of pipe options and you do not know where to begin?

YiTong Product Page

If you do not understand what a corrugated steel pipe is, not to worry! You are covered. A corrugated steel pipe is simply a pipe whose body is made up of stainless steel and designed with different types of joints. This type of pipe has a ring-shaped outer wall and a smooth inner wall.

Here are some reasons why you need a corrugated steel pipe:

It can be easily transported from one point to another

When most people hear the word ‘metal’, they often believe that the material is generally heavy and they would need lots of support in carrying it. But that is not the same as our metal corrugated pipes. While it is certain that a lot of metals hold substantial weight, the weight of this pipe is only a fraction of the weight of a concrete pipe that even has the same size. The fraction is about 1/10 to 1/5. You can even move it about without the aid of a machine. This is why it is often used for protection. It is used to protect communication cables transmitted underneath, protect pipes used to transport gas and pipes generally used for construction purposes.

For more Corrugated Metal Culvert Pipeinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.

The strength of a corrugated steel pipe is second to none

The strength of a corrugated steel pipe is enormous. Unlike other types, this particular corrugated pipe has a higher compression strength (more than 1.5 times stronger), so it is better able to withstand heavy pressures and external forces. It is very suitable for use in drainage facilities such as golf course drain, factory drain, domestic sewage, airport water drain, underground garage or any other related facility, etc.

Installation and de-installation times are relatively short

Metal corrugated pipes are often connected by fastening the band together with a clamp. Plus, the length is not specific- it is changed or adjusted based on the client’s or customers’ requests. So, it is easier to install or de-install these pipes, relatively compared to concrete pipes that are fixed to a particular position. This makes corrugated steel culvert pipes a perfect choice for farm and agricultural purposes. It can be used to drain farm water or for irrigation.

Its durability rate is high

When you use a metal corrugated pipe, be assured that it will last for long periods. Under normal circumstances, this pipe can serve between fifty to a hundred years. But if affected by environmental conditions, the lifespan can reduce to about twenty to fifty years. Either way, they still serve long periods. That is why it is suitable for industrial purposes such as creating air channels or tubes for gases to flow through in coal mines. Sweet, isn’t it?

For more information, please visit Tunnell Lliner.